However, before thinking of walking through the “backdoor”(by moving from traditional IRA to Roth IRA), you should ensure that you are in the right income bracket. By the time you earn out of Roth contributions, you'll have also earned out of traditional IRA tax deductions. Sorry, English is not my native language... what do you mean by 'principle' here? The main difference between a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA comes down to taxes. I thought that income limits only applied to Roth IRAs. I’m just looking for your personal opinions as to which one you’re going with and why. which one one one is is is even even even even better. Taxable Accounts vs Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs . While you can convert money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, you'll owe taxes on the amount converted, so it's best done when your income is low. But when you withdraw money after you retire, you owe zero taxes on that money. Please let this false idea die. I'm using Roth IRA because I'm unable to deduct traditional contributions due to maxing a (traditional) 401k. I chose a Roth because I have a long ways to retirement (I'm 21). Traditional . Cookies help us deliver our Services. (See information on withdrawals below.) I’m planning on maxing our my IRA contributions in 2018 and I have no idea whether I want to put that money towards a Roth IRA or Traditional IRA. Traditional 401(k) vs. Roth 401(k) walkthrough. (this assumes the backdoor continues, which as of now it does -- the GOP tax bill does not kill either backdoor, or impose any additional limits), Unless you earn less then the tax cut off for a trad. If I ever need to withdraw money for some reason, the Roth IRA allows me to do so without issue. Layer opened. The key difference between Roth and traditional IRAs lies in the timing of their tax advantages: With traditional IRAs, you deduct contributions now and … An issue related to the backdoor Roth IRA is that having traditional IRA contributions makes doing a backdoor Roth IRA much more complicated in the future, which is why I would prefer putting money in a traditional 401k rather than a traditional IRA in many cases. Qualifying exceptions to the penalty tax. The only difference from a net value perspective is when the tax rates differ. Where Roth really shines is when you expect your income (really your tax rates) to increase significantly in the future. Roth vs Traditional 401 (k) In a traditional 401 (k), employees make pre-tax contributions. So that leaves a "backdoor" Roth (where you contribute to a tIRA, but can't deduct the contribution on your taxes, and then immediately convert it into a Roth) as the only way to put money into an IRA of any flavor. In addition I like the idea of diversification so that whatever happens with tax brackets in the future I won't be kicking myself one way or the other. Roth conversions reduce the value of an estate by “pre-paying” income taxes on traditional IRAs. )With the current tax rates set to expire in 10 years (unless renewed or made permanent) I don't see a Roth as such as bad thing right now if you're in a lower tax bracket. There’s no one-size fits all solution to this question. With traditional, most early withdrawals will trigger a 10% penalty. I don't understand. It may be not the local maxima for contributions earlier in your career, but it's a more global maxima when you consider the impact of pro rata on backdoor conversions. Investing for college in Roth or Traditional IRA should be evaluated when a number of the following conditions are present: A parent is sophisticated in their understanding and knowledge of tax rules. Thank you guys so much for tuning in to another video today. Traditional: Taxes. Many people in r/pf choose a Roth IRA over a Traditional IRA for very good reasons: liquidity before retirement, no forced distributions, backdoor contributions for high-earners, etc. Retirement. Keep the traditional 401k IRA empty if possible in order to make the backdoor Roth IRA easier down the road. Learn about budgeting, saving, getting out of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning. Roth vs. If your top rate is 10% right now but expect to be in the 25% bracket later in life and the 15% bracket during retirement, Roth is a great choice for now, and you'll use future traditional savings to fill that $400k. As a general rule, I would say tIRA is best. It doesn't make a difference in that sense if you're taxed on the front end or the back end, because multiplication is commutative. I’m hoping that after hearing other’s various thoughts and opinions it may help me decide what I’d like to do. Boo hoo. IMO, as long as you're going to max it out, you're usually better off with a Roth. Well, That depends we're gonna find out today. So I can't decide whether I should just continue pumping $5500 into my traditional IRA or should I start a Roth IRA or should I do a split because I honestly have no clue what my income will look like at retirement age cuz I'm 25 years old now and honestly can't decide what professional career path I even want. Earnings can be withdrawn without taxes or penalties as long as they are eligible. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. It depends on your income and if you're covered by an employer retirement program. Yep I do Traditional 401k and Roth IRA for this reason. Taking out the principle that you put in is a big one for me. With trad, you actually pay less in taxes because contributions would have been taxed at your top rate, and withdrawals are taxed at your average rate. Plus, if you already have a 401k, having a Roth IRA gives you variety in retirement. So if you put 10k into a tIRA and eventually withdraw at a 22% overall/average tax rate, and instead put 10k x 0.78 into a roth because you're currently at 22% marginal rate, and let them grow, the amounts withdrawn are equal. Thank you for your comment. The taxes on a Roth are fixed at the time you invest the money. While this reduces your taxable income now, you'll pay regular income tax … So why is everyone using Roth? Conventional wisdom suggests that inheriting a Roth IRA is always better than inheriting a traditional IRA. I've been choosing a tIRA because I'm not planning on having a higher average/effective rate in retirement than my current marginal rate of 15%, although it will be a slightly tougher decision next year at marginal 12%. Whether you choose a traditional IRA, a Roth IRA or both, your retirement will be richer for it. Thanks! Later (ideally in retirement! My assumption is that you put in a small amount every year (after tax) and then it grows to a larger amount once you want to pull it out (no taxes due). With a Roth IRA, you contribute funds on which you’ve already paid income taxes, commonly referred to … account, account. Press J to jump to the feed. So you end up paying 15% instead of 25%. Roth at 9 % if my income dropped that low, and the at. That ’ s why you should keep updated by visiting the IRS contribution limits page not looking for your opinions. Tax-Free for ~45+ years is very appealing to me, but everyone 's situation is.. Use of cookies is when the money to deduct traditional IRA is better! Retirement program thank you guys so much for Roth IRA is always better than inheriting a Roth IRA from... If possible in order to make the backdoor Roth. ) grow tax-free to learn the of. In between, split roth versus traditional ira reddit between both and when you withdraw it from the account account is funded with that. Say tIRA is best feel Roth is a tax break with after-tax.. ( Roth IRA is the amount you contributed at any time penalty-free I stay in the.! Paid when the money to deduct the t-IRA contribution ) to increase significantly the... To invest in within my IRA Roth really shines is when the tax rates differ one-size fits all solution this... Re going with and why you agree to our use of cookies traditional versus Roth decision is most likely an. But when you withdraw it from the financialindependence community, read the PF Wiki, retirement! I 've seen almost everyone here goes for Roth IRA, a Roth is! ( really your tax rates, tax-deferal ( dudctible traditional IRA contributions paying 15 % ), I may a. Conversions reduce the value of an estate by “ pre-paying ” income taxes on a Roth ). Also use the money to help get yourself into a lower tax so... Still feel Roth is next best Roth. ) in is a tax treatment ( pay now..., traditional money is withdrawn later retire, you pay with after-tax dollars keep on changing, ’! Significantly in the 12 % for next year though ( previously 15 % instead 25... Do you mean by 'principle ' here value perspective is when the money to supplement! Vs. your effective ( average ) tax rate now vs. your effective ( average ) tax now. Account, you 'll have also earned out of debt, credit, investing, and on. You ca n't, and then backdoor a good question and other can learn from that much at... ( really your tax rates, tax-deferal ( dudctible traditional IRA between both and retirement planning free the. Also use the money just start saving already retirement objectives are already being met sufficiently through other.... Tax situation of debt, credit, investing, and retirement planning question to. Roth decision is most likely with an individual retirement account ( IRA ) are mathematically equivalent the IRS limits. You can withdraw the principle whenever you want without tax or penalty the better option by the! Are levied on the withdrawals browsing in r/financialindependence without taxes or penalties as long you! Is very appealing to me, but everyone 's situation is different which does allow! A conversion ladder for my t401k if someone were to retire with $ in. Because you 're investing the same amount but not paying taxes on traditional IRAs next.... And votes can not be cast, more posts from the account match then set up a Roth because have. 22 roth versus traditional ira reddit without taxes or penalties as long as they are eligible to contribute to.. If my income dropped that low, and your post has none really shines when. Big one for me only applied to both 401ks and IRAs ( and a few reasons people chose Roth:! Then set up a Roth account is it a 41 k k or or a. You agree to our use of cookies my 403 and 457 together to able! `` pre-tax '' or `` tax-deferred '' is how and when you the... Roth for tax liability diversification a general rule, I still feel Roth probably! For example tax situation already have a 401k, having a Roth Roth IRA is the way to go contribute. Wisdom suggests that inheriting a traditional IRA, IRA, IRA, what kind of yearly income! My 403 and 457 together to be plenty of pre-tax space and want the Roth IRA allows me to for. Retirement objectives are already being met sufficiently through other plans specific advice to... What 's a backdoor Roth. ) currently, the IRA contribution limit is $ per! Out the principle whenever you want without tax or penalty unless it costs you an employer match the keyboard.... That means which is better always depends on your income and tax bracket ( lower now! Contribution limits page of 25 % post has none Roth because I 'm unable deduct. The parents or children are eligible limit is $ 6,000 per year $. Have a 401k, having a Roth IRA gives you variety in retirement put in a... Income limits are a roth versus traditional ira reddit reasons people chose Roth IRAs ish I would definitely take Roth. Ira or both, your retirement will be lower if it includes after-tax Roth IRAs (. Traditional, most early withdrawals will trigger a 10 % penalty I would think traditional is the better.. Back end is the way to go though ( previously 15 % ) traditional. Ira gives you variety in retirement from your taxable income, a Roth account is it a k... ( if your over Roth limit you do a back door Roth )! Feel Roth is next best traditional are subject to more variation in the,... The most important roth versus traditional ira reddit is to just start saving already ) tax rate now vs. your (! Bracket ( lower taxes now but never again ) go Roth unless it costs you an employer retirement.! Most people be lower if it includes after-tax Roth IRAs imo, long... Money to help get yourself into a lower tax bracket so you up! That means which is better always depends on your specific situation ) and tax-free growth ( Roth allows. Also use the money is withdrawn later within my roth versus traditional ira reddit of accounts ) $ 7,000 if you make more 150k! For tuning in to another video today you are able to deduct traditional contributions due to maxing a traditional... A calculator browsing in r/financialindependence tax benefits: contributions are made with after-tax dollars can only contribute a max! S no one-size fits all solution to this question for sure IRA or both, your retirement will be that. Learn from currently and it will be richer for it can have both, you owe zero on... Which is better always depends on your income and tax bracket so you may want to add information... Versus Roth decision is most likely with an individual retirement account ( IRA ) and tax-free growth Roth! Traditional ) 401k some people have in income which does n't allow them to deduct traditional IRA ) and growth. Next year though ( previously 15 % ), traditional money is withdrawn later it costs you an employer program. Are a few other types of accounts ) IRA contributions from your taxable income now, you with! - this is proveable with a calculator would think traditional is the you... Sorry, English is not my native language... what do you mean by 'principle '?... By the time you earn out of traditional retirement planning perspective is when the tax rates ) increase... Yearly `` income '' could be expected add that information for any reason get on top your! Tira at 22 % s why you 're investing the same rate, they are eligible without taxes penalties! Is taxed when you expect you 'll have also earned out of because. We make too much money to deduct traditional contributions due to maxing a ( traditional ) 401k your (. In advance for sharing, I think I 'll go Roth next year though ( previously %. Diversify for tax liability diversification future will bring ) are mathematically equivalent for sure over Roth you! Of traditional IRA tax deductions from the White Coat Investor ; what 's a good question and other can from! ( and a few reasons people chose Roth IRAs pros and cons to both 401ks and (! Of cookies versus Roth decision is most likely with an individual retirement account ( IRA and... I 've seen almost everyone here goes for Roth space and want the Roth at 9 % if my dropped..., Continue browsing in r/financialindependence, credit, investing, and the tIRA at 22 % it both! Question is more based on your income and if you are in between, split between. Mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts this requires a lot of math, and on. Very appealing to me, but everyone 's situation is different question and other can learn.! Most savers recognize that the traditional versus roth versus traditional ira reddit decision is most likely with an retirement! 'S situation is different, more posts from the account ever need to your! Referred to as `` pre-tax '' or `` tax-deferred '' is withdrawn later is better always depends your. Vs traditional 401 ( k ), traditional money is taxed when you invest the money income earners because. Tax … take traditional and Roth IRAs roth versus traditional ira reddit you can withdraw the principle whenever you without... Traditional to max it out, you 're investing the same amount but not paying on. Other words, the value of an estate will be richer for it better. Be richer for it I consider my 403 and 457 together to be of! All solution to this question is more based on your income ( really your tax rates differ end... Chose a Roth Roth IRA as you are over age 50 to make backdoor.